Select Page

Ranking McDonald’s McFlurry Flavors From Worst to Best

McDonald’s McFlurry is one of the best-known desserts around the world. Since it was first introduced in 1997, McDonald’s has been combining some of the most popular candies with its soft serve vanilla ice cream to create this unique sweet treat.

The McFlurry has become so popular that it is now available in nearly 100 countries, each of which has come up with its own unique combinations.

The original McFlurry flavors were Oreo, Heath, Nestle Crunch, M&M’s, and Butterfinger.

Since then, McDonald’s has swirled many other popular candies and desserts into their vanilla soft serve. Naturally, some flavors have been more popular than others, but the variety allows everyone to find a McFlurry they love.  

The Oreo McFlurry and the M&M McFlurry are currently the two standard flavors served at McDonald’s in the US, but many other combinations have come and gone.

To help you not miss out the next time your favorite combo makes a comeback, we’ve taken 12 McFlurry flavors that have made it to US menus and ranked them from worst to best.  

12. M&M’s

The M&M McFlurry is one of the two standard McFlurry flavors found in McDonald’s restaurants across the US.

Colorful chocolate M&M candies are swirled into sweet and creamy vanilla soft serve to create a fun take on two old favorites.

The rainbow colors make this sweet treat fun, especially when they start to change the ice cream colors.

However, the cold soft serve makes the M&M’s hard to chew, so you might need patience to really enjoy this combo.

M&M’s also don’t disperse throughout the ice cream in the same way that sauces and crumbly toppings do, and for these reasons, we’ve placed the M&M’s McFlurry at the bottom of our list.  

The M&M McFlurry comes in a regular or snack size.

A regular M&M McFlurry has 640 calories, and the smaller snack size has 420 calories.

The two common allergens found in the M&M McFlurry are milk and soy.

11. Pralines & Cream

The Pralines & Cream McFlurry was a favorite while it lasted, but this flavor sadly hasn’t been available for some time.

McDonald’s discontinued the Pralines & Cream McFlurry back in 2015 with no plans for its return, but those who had the opportunity to try it remember it fondly.

Pralines are sugar-coated pecans, which on their own are already great.

Swirled into creamy vanilla soft serve and topped with hot caramel sauce, the Pralines & Cream McFlurry had the perfect sundae trifecta of ice cream, crunch, and sauce.

10. Butterfinger

The Butterfinger McFlurry doesn’t quite look like a classic sundae, but it has all the makings of one.

Butterfinger candies are layers of thin and crispy peanut butter coated in a milk chocolate shell.

These candies are broken up and swirled in creamy vanilla soft serve to create the sweet and crunchy Butterfinger McFlurry.

You can’t go wrong in combining peanut butter, chocolate, and vanilla ice cream.

Although this flavor has been discontinued, the Butterfinger McFlurry was so popular that fans are still petitioning to bring it back.

9. Stroopwafel

The Stroopwafel McFlurry started as a Dutch favorite on the international menu and became a fan favorite when it made its debut on US menus in June 2019.

It was one of four international menu items that made a limited-time appearance.

The others were the Grand McExtreme Bacon Burger from Spain, the Tomato-Mozzarella Chicken Sandwich from Canada, and Cheesy Bacon Fries from Australia.

Caramel stroopwafel crumbles and caramel sauce are swirled throughout a cup of McDonald’s soft serve to create this popular McFlurry from the Netherlands.

The thin stroopwafel is made by Daelmans, a well-known stroopwafel maker, similar to a thin waffle cone.

It is crisp with a gooey caramel center and offers notes of cinnamon to top it off.

8. Caramel Brownie

The Caramel Brownie McFlurry is the newest flavor featured on the US menu.

It made its debut in the summer of 2021 and was announced on National Caramel Day a month before its release.  

It includes chocolate brownie pieces and caramel sauce swirled throughout soft serve vanilla ice cream.

Brownies and ice cream are undeniably a fantastic combination, and caramel sauce adds another layer of deliciousness.

Although this McFlurry was a bit heavier than others, it still made a great summer treat, and fans are crossing their fingers for its return.

The regular Caramel Brownie McFlurry has around 630 calories, and the snack size has 470.

The common allergens found in the Caramel Brownie McFlurry are milk, soy, gluten, and eggs.

7. Rolo

Rolo candies are made of creamy chocolate filled with decadent caramel.

A Rolo McFlurry takes pieces of these candies and swirls them into creamy vanilla soft serve ice cream.

Chocolate pieces and sweet caramel swirls give this McFlurry a fun texture and make every bite different.

Together, we get three classic flavors in one delicious dessert.

You can’t go wrong with the classic flavor combination of a Rolo McFlurry.

It was most recently re-released in 2018 when McDonald’s announced that they were no longer using artificial colors, flavors, or preservatives in their restaurants.

Although it was only around for a limited time, we hope to enjoy it again soon because it aligns with the restaurant’s newest menu changes.

6. Snickerdoodle

The Snickerdoodle McFlurry made its debut in time for the holidays in 2019.

Although it was the first holiday McFlurry to be released in seven years, it was only available to order through Uber Eats.

However, it’s hard to predict what McDonald’s will roll out next, and we can only hope to see it return.

Sugar cookie crumbles, cinnamon, and white chocolate pieces are swirled into vanilla soft serve to create the Snickerdoodle McFlurry.

It’s sweet, cinnamon spicy, and it has a bit of chew that gives nice texture variety.

The flavors were reportedly more intense than other McFlurry combinations, but that means this McFlurry is sure to cure a sweet tooth.

5. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup

The Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup McFlurry was discontinued back in 2012, but people are still talking about it.

This McFlurry crumbled Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup and mixed them into vanilla soft serve so that each bit contained a balance of ice cream, chocolate, and creamy peanut butter.

There have been no reports of the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup McFlurry making a comeback, but fans may soon be treated to new peanut butter and chocolate McFlurry.

Although there haven’t been any official announcements, there are rumors around McDonald’s testing a new peanut butter crunch McFlurry.

It was first spotted in Pasadena, California, and reportedly includes chocolate and cookie pieces with a strong overall peanut butter flavor.

4. Shamrock McFlurry

The Shamrock Shake has been a seasonal McDonald’s favorite since 1970, and McDonald’s debuted the Oreo Shamrock McFlurry in 2020.

It is made of vanilla soft serve with the signature Shamrock Shake flavor and Oreo Cookies throughout for a minty cookie combination reminiscent of thin mint cookies.

Shamrock McFlurry is one of the flavors that makes a regular comeback, which is a testament to its popularity.

The Oreo Shamrock McFlurry has a fun green color, is refreshing in its minty sweet flavor, and has joined the Shamrock Shake as a seasonal treat.

A regular Oreo Shamrock McFlurry has around 560 calories, and the snack size has 370.

The common allergens found in the Oreo Shamrock McFlurry are milk, soy, and gluten.

3. Twix

The Twix McFlurry is like three desserts in one. It is made of chocolate-coated cookie pieces, and chocolate caramel sauce swirled into vanilla ice cream.

Just like the famous candy bar, the Twix McFlurry excels in flavor and texture variety.

The Twix McFlurry was discontinued in the US, but it may not be forever.

After it returned to the UK in 2019, fans remain hopeful that it will soon make a return to the US.

2. Snickers

The Snickers McFlurry has all of the necessary components for a great sundae swirled together so that each bite is packed with flavor.

This McFlurry is also filled with textures as it combines crunchy peanuts, gooey caramel sauce, chocolate-covered nougat pieces, and creamy vanilla ice cream.

1. Oreo McFlurry

The Oreo McFlurry is one of the most popular McFlurry flavors and one of the two main McFlurries available across the US.

It takes creamy and crunchy Oreo cookie crumbles and mixes them into vanilla soft serve ice cream.

It’s sweet and crunchy, and the cookie crumbles distribute throughout the McFlurry for a perfect combination in every bite.

Although this may not be the most unique McFlurry that has made it to US menus, it checks off all our boxes and can be ordered whenever the craving hits.

The flavors of chocolate and vanilla are distinct, while cookies distribute well throughout the ice cream, and the bit of crunch is tasty and satisfying.

The Oreo McFlurry comes in a regular or snack size.

A regular Oreo McFlurry has 510 calories, and a snack size has 340.

The common allergens found in the Oreo McFlurry are milk, soy, and gluten.

Conclusion

McFlurries come in many flavor combinations, and it’s not hard to see why they have become a popular dessert in countries throughout the world.

With seemingly endless combinations, we never know what unique flavor McDonald’s will come out next.

Many of these flavors are only around for a limited time, so keep an eye out for your favorite and grab one while you can.  

If you’re looking for more tips about McDonald’s, check out the articles below.

Related Articles:

McDonald’s Desserts: What You Need to Know Before Ordering

McDonald’s Burgers: Exploring All Fan-Favorite Burgers at McDonald’s

Does McDonald’s Serve Breakfast All Day? (A Must-Read Guide!)

What to Know About McDonald’s Apple Pie (Interesting Facts)

What to Know About McChicken and McDonald’s Crispy Chicken Sandwiches

Was this article helpful?

Last Updated: April 14, 2022

About the Author

Lana Kisner is a writer on the Shopfood.com team. She has a B.A. in European Literary Studies and over two years of experience as a content and copywriter. She loves food and people and has spent more than 15 years in the foodservice industry.

In her free time, she enjoys traveling and exploring new places, live music, and hiking with her dog.

Recent Articles

Disclosure: Shopfood.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon. Shopfood.com also participates in other affiliate programs and is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies, but there is absolutely no additional cost to you if you make a purchase using our links.