Select Page

Your Guide to Ordering Cakes From the Wegmans Bakery

If you have a special event or celebration coming up, but you don’t have time to bake and decorate a cake, Wegmans bakery can be your solution.

Wegmans bakery offers graduation cakes, birthday cakes, photo cakes, wedding cakes, and more for every occasion. Wegmans bakeries are open from 10 am to 9 pm, seven days a week. Wegmans also makes custom cakes with many flavors, fillings, and decorations. You can order a custom cake from Wegmans online or in person.

In this article, we’ll cover everything you need to know about ordering cakes from the Wegmans bakery!

What Are Wegmans Bakery Hours?

Wegmans bakery is open from 10 am to 9 pm, seven days a week. This is different from regular store hours, 6 am to 12 am. Wegmans bakery is closed on Christmas and closes early on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, and New Year’s Eve. Some stores may have different hours, so confirm your local store’s hours online.

You can order a cake from Wegmans bakery any day of the week. At most Wegmans stores, the bakery opens at 10 am.

The actual store opens much earlier, at 6 am. If you plan to visit the bakery during a regular grocery trip, keep this in mind.

The bakery’s closing time also differs from the regular store hours. Most Wegmans bakeries close at 9 pm, while the main store closes at midnight.

Most Wegmans stores and bakeries are open on every holiday except Christmas. So if you want a cake for Christmas, make sure you schedule it in time so it can be ready by Christmas Eve.

Of course, you’ll also have to ensure you can pick up the cake before 6 pm if it’s on Christmas Eve.

The Wegmans bakery closes early on Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, and New Year’s Eve as most stores close at 6 pm instead of 9 pm, though individual stores may vary.

However, any Wegmans store can differ from the regular business hours. Therefore, visit the Wegmans store finder online to get the most up-to-date hours for the location you plan to visit.

Here is a table showing the regular Wegmans bakery hours:

DaysWegmans Bakery Hours
Monday10 am- 9 pm
Tuesday10 am- 9 pm
Wednesday10 am- 9 pm
Thursday10 am- 9 pm
Friday10 am- 9 pm
Saturday10 am- 9 pm
Sunday10 am- 9 pm

Here is a table showing the Wegmans bakery holiday hours:

HolidayWegmans Bakery Hours
New Year’s Day10 am- 9 pm
Good Friday10 am- 9 pm
Easter10 am- 9 pm
Memorial Day10 am- 9 pm
4th of July10 am- 9 pm
Labor Day10 am- 9 pm
Thanksgiving10 am- 6 pm
Black Friday10 am- 9 pm
Christmas Eve10 am- 6 pm
Christmas DayClosed 
New Year’s Eve10 am- 6 pm

How to Order a Cake From Wegmans

You can order a premade or custom cake from Wegmans by visiting your local store’s bakery or placing an order online. Premade cakes can be added to any Curbside Pickup or Delivery order, while custom cakes are ordered through the Wegmans catering service. You can browse the Wegmans cake catalog to determine your cake design.

Premade cakes are just like any other grocery item. If you are shopping in a Wegmans store, you can visit the bakery department and pick up whichever cake you want.

If you don’t see anything that fits your needs perfectly, ask the bakery employees if they have anything else in the back.

If you still can’t find what you want, you may need to place a custom cake order with a bakery associate.

Here’s a tip for shopping in-store: you can preview items available at your local Wegmans on the website.

Even if you don’t plan to purchase anything until you get to the store, you can browse the departments and see the current prices of the items. You can also add items to a shopping list that can be printed.

You can also add premade cakes to your Wegmans online order. This includes Curbside Pickup and Delivery orders.

Wegmans bakery offers a variety of cakes, including gluten-free cakes, that can be added to your cart while shopping online.

Custom cakes can also be ordered online from Wegmans, but this is done through a different webpage.

Any custom order is considered a meal or catering order, so you will need to use the Wegmans catering page to order a custom cake under the “Cakes & Desserts” section.

There are three options for how you will receive your custom cake: Curbside Pickup, Delivery, or Carryout.

Even if you don’t plan to order online, it can be helpful to visit this catering page because it serves as the Wegmans cake catalog.

You can view all the design and flavor options you will have to choose from at the bakery.

If you have any questions, you can always call the Wegmans bakery phone number, which can be found using the store locator.

Can You Order a Cake From Wegmans Online?

You can order both premade and custom cakes from Wegmans online. There are a few standard premade cakes sold at most Wegmans bakeries. If these don’t work, you can order a custom cake and choose your cake’s size, flavor, colors, and decorations. Most Wegmans custom cakes need to be ordered at least 24 hours in advance.

To order a premade cake from Wegmans online, you simply need to add it to your cart while shopping online.

You can find the right cake by browsing the Bakery section online or directly searching for an item. Some favorites include birthday cakes and Wegmans red velvet cakes.

Since a premade cake would be included in a regular grocery order, it can only be ordered up to 6 days in advance.

Wegmans bakeries produce fresh cakes every day, so you likely won’t need to order too far in advance, but a last-minute order risks you not getting the cake you want.

Custom cakes can also be ordered online through the Wegmans catering site called Meals 2Go.

You can place custom cake orders up to 30 days in advance but no less than 24 hours before picking up the cake.

The ordering process for a custom cake is simple. First, you’ll need to select the type of cake you want (sheet, round, or gluten-free). Then, you’ll specify the size and flavors of your cake, filling, and frosting.

Finally, you’ll need to choose whether you want decorations and a personalized message added to the top of the cake. Read on to the next section for more details on this process.

After customizing your cake, add it to your cart. You can add more than one catering item to your cart.

This is helpful if you plan to serve other food along with the cake or if you need more than one custom cake for a large crowd.

When you checkout, you will need to confirm how you will receive your custom order. Make sure you have the right Wegmans location selected in this step!

Wegmans employees are happy to bring your custom cake out to your car for curbside pickup.

They can also prepare the cake for delivery. These orders are delivered through DoorDash, so an extra fee may be added to your order.

It is important to confirm your order is correct before submitting it because you will not be able to change anything once submitted.

If you realize something is incorrect, you can call the store you ordered from at the number sent in your confirmation email.

Does Wegmans Make Custom Cakes?

Wegmans makes custom cakes for any occasion. When you order a custom cake from Wegmans, you can select the cake’s size, flavors, and design. There are plenty of options to choose from, especially for the cake filling. You need to order custom cakes at least 24 hours in advance from the Wegmans bakery.

The first step in making a custom Wegmans cake is selecting the type of cake you want.

There are four options: cookie cakes, sheet cakes, 7-inch round cakes, and gluten-free cakes.

If you are highly sensitive to gluten, note that gluten-free cakes are made without gluten-containing ingredients, but they are still subject to cross-contamination.

Once you pick the type of your custom cake, you will then select the size of the cake.

Wegmans cookie cakes can be made as a full sheet, ½ sheet, or ¼ sheet. The full sheet serves up to 40 people, while the ¼ sheet serves 8-10 people.

Wegmans sheet cakes usually are available in these same sizes, but ongoing shortages have limited the sizes to a ½ sheet and ¼ sheet only.

Wegmans gluten-free cakes are only available as sheet cakes, but there is a larger variety of sizes. Specifically, a gluten-free cake can be made as a full sheet, ½ sheet, ¼ sheet, or ⅛ sheet.

Finally, there is a round cake option. Round custom cakes are made as one or two layers, all with 7-inch rounds.

The next step to customizing your cake is choosing the flavors, frosting, and filling.

The Wegmans cake flavors are gold and chocolate. A regular sheet cake (not gluten-free) can also be made with a marble flavor or half gold and half chocolate.

The Wegmans frosting flavors include white or chocolate buttercream, whipped cream, and white or chocolate ultimate cream. You really can’t go wrong with any of the frosting choices!

You can also choose to add a filling in between layers of the cake, and there are plenty of choices.

The Wegmans cake filling options are custard, chocolate custard, lemon, cherry, seedless raspberry, blueberry, cannoli cream, fresh strawberries, fresh blueberries, fresh raspberries, fresh strawberries, and custard, and fresh mixed fruit.

All Wegmans cake fillings cost extra, ranging from $10 to $32 on a standard ½ sheet cake.

Decorations can be selected after all the flavors are chosen. Most Wegmans cake designs are quite simplistic.

You can choose to have white chocolate balloons or piped roses atop your cake. If you decide to add either of these elements, you can select up to 3 colors for the balloons or roses.

Wegmans bakers can also print an edible photo onto the top of your cake.

All you need to do is upload the photo when ordering online, and they will print it at an appropriate size for whichever cake style you order.

You can also upload a photo depicting a theme that you want your cake to reflect.

Perhaps you are having a superhero-themed birthday party, and you want a Wegmans character cake that will match the theme.

Uploading a photo of some party decorations can help give the cake decorators an idea of what you want to see on your cake.

Finally, the Wegmans cake order form includes a space to add a personalized message.

If you want a message written in frosting on top of your cake, type it out exactly as you want it written in the space provided.

If you are going through this ordering process and realize something is missing, feel free to reach out to your local Wegmans bakery.

The bakery employees will be happy to help you come up with the perfect design for your cake!

What Are Wegmans Cake Prices?

Wegmans cake prices range from $17 to $119 and up. Your cake price will depend on many factors, especially if the cake is custom-made. Adding a filling to your cake or ordering a gluten-free cake will increase the price. However, Wegmans cake prices are still affordable for the number of people they serve.

Wegmans’ regular sheet cakes are currently only available as a ¼ sheet or ½ sheet at most locations due to shortages of ingredients.

The ¼ sheet cake starts at $28, but it will be more expensive if you choose to add a filling or additional decorations beyond what is included.

A ½ sheet cake is only $16 more for double the servings.

For slightly smaller gatherings, a 7-inch round cake may be more appropriate. A single-layer round cake costs only $17, and it serves up to 8 people.

The double-layer round cake is $25 and serves up to 12 people.

Wegmans is distinguished from other supermarkets as it offers excellent gluten-free options at its bakery.

You can get a sheet cake, ranging from a ⅛ sheet to a full sheet, made without gluten-containing ingredients.

Gluten-free cakes generally cost more due to the more expensive ingredients, but they are still affordable and a great time-saver.

Here are the base prices for Wegmans cakes:

SizeNumber of ServingsPrice
Regular ¼ Sheet15-18$28
Regular ½ Sheet30-36$44
Gluten-Free ⅛ Sheet6-8$22
Gluten-Free ¼ Sheet15-18$37
Gluten-Free ½ Sheet30-36$63
Gluten-Free Full Sheet60-72$119
7-Inch Round, 1 Layer6-8$17
7-Inch Round, 2 Layers8-12$25
* Wegmans cake prices may vary by location

Does Wegmans Make Wedding Cakes?

Wegmans does not advertise that they make wedding cakes, but you can order a wedding cake from the Wegmans bakery. They offer sheet cakes and round cakes that can be decorated for a wedding. You can customize the cake’s colors to match the color palette of your wedding decor and upload a theme photo for inspiration.

The Wegmans cake order form does not give too many design options. Instead, it is up to the customer to provide additional information if they have a specific idea in mind.

For a wedding cake, you may just want a simple white cake with beautiful roses piped on top.

Or you may want a photo of the couple getting married. If you have a theme picked out for the wedding decor, you can submit a photo of this theme for the cake decorator to replicate.

When you are planning something as important as a wedding, we recommend that you call your local Wegmans bakery to speak directly with one of the cake decorators.

They can give you more insight into what kinds of decorations can be added and how much they will cost.

Does Wegmans Bake Their Own Cakes?

Wegmans does not bake their own cakes. Instead, most cakes are baked offsite and delivered to individual Wegmans bakeries. Then, cake decorators at the bakery frost and decorate cakes to order. Since Wegmans cakes are in high demand, they are delivered daily to most stores and remain fresh and moist.

Although the Wegmans bakery has fresh baked goods, it does not bake all its cakes every day.

This would be an overwhelming task requiring much more space than in a typical Wegmans bakery.

Instead, cakes are baked at a large facility and distributed to individual Wegmans locations, often frozen.

Then, the cakes can be defrosted as they are needed. Freezing the cakes helps preserve their moisture to provide a delicious cake every time.


Wegmans can cater to various occasions and tastes with its premade and custom cakes. You can get a great deal on the perfect dessert for your next birthday or graduation celebration.

Stop by the Wegmans bakery on your next grocery trip to pick up a delicious treat!

If you’re interested in finding out more grocery shopping tips, check out the related articles below.

Related Articles:

How Wegmans Curbside Pickup Works and How to Order on the Wegmans App

Wegmans Delivery: How It Works and How to Order Using the Wegmans App

Here’s What You Need to Know About the Whole Foods Chantilly Cake

Whole Foods Cakes: Your Guide to Ordering Cakes From Whole Foods Bakery

Whole Foods Delivery: How to Order Online With Amazon Prime

About the Author

Alex Burgess is a registered dietitian and content creator with over two years of experience. She loves sharing nutrition information and has a passion for studying gut health.

During her free time, she enjoys hiking with friends, cooking a new recipe for her family, or watching her dog frolic at the dog park.

November 12, 2022