Select Page

Your Guide to Ordering Cakes From the Sam’s Club Bakery

Think back to the last birthday party you attended. There was probably a moment when everyone gathered to sing “Happy Birthday” and then enjoy a decorative piece of cake. If you aren’t familiar with the cakes that Sam’s Club Bakery sells, you need to read this article to learn everything you need to know about Sam’s Club cakes.

Sam’s Club Bakery offers graduation cakes, birthday cakes, photo cakes, wedding cakes, and more. Sam’s Club bakeries are open from 10 am to 8 pm on weekdays and Sundays and from 9 am to 8 pm on Saturdays. While you can order premade cakes from Sam’s Club online, custom cake orders can only be placed in Sam’s Club stores.

Keep on reading to find out how to make the most of your next Sam’s Club cake order!

What Are Sam’s Club Bakery Hours?

Sam’s Club Bakery is open from 10 am to 8 pm on weekdays and Sundays. The bakery is open one extra hour on Saturdays, from 9 am to 8 pm. The Sam’s Club Bakery is closed on New Year’s Day, Easter, Thanksgiving, and Christmas. It also closes early on certain holidays, including Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve.

Most Sam’s Club stores follow the same regular schedule every day. However, hours can slightly vary by location.

Thus, you may want to check the Club Finder online to confirm when your local Sam’s Club is open.

Holiday hours are essentially storewide. All Sam’s Club stores are closed on New Year’s Day, Easter, Thanksgiving, and Christmas Day.

So, make sure you get all your holiday shopping done at least one day before these major holidays.

Sam’s Club stores also close early on Memorial Day, the 4th of July, Labor Day, Christmas Eve, and New Year’s Eve. Generally, the stores still open at 10 am, but they close at 6 pm instead of 8 pm.

Sam’s Club remains open for its regular hours on Good Friday and Black Friday.

Below tables display the Sam’s Club Bakery hours for regular days and holidays:

DaysSam’s Club Bakery Hours
Monday10 am- 8 pm
Tuesday10 am- 8 pm
Wednesday10 am- 8 pm
Thursday10 am- 8 pm
Friday10 am- 8 pm
Saturday9 am- 8 pm
Sunday10 am- 8 pm

HolidaySam’s Club Bakery Hours
New Year’s DayClosed
Good Friday10 am- 8 pm
EasterClosed
Memorial Day10 am- 6 pm
4th of July10 am- 6 pm
Labor Day10 am- 6 pm
ThanksgivingClosed
Black Friday10 am- 8 pm
Christmas Eve10 am- 6 pm
Christmas DayClosed
New Year’s Eve10 am- 6 pm

How to Order a Cake From Sam’s Club

To order a cake from Sam’s Club, you can use the Sam’s Club website or place an order in person. Many premade cakes are available daily for purchase in-store. You can also place a custom cake order with a baker at Sam’s Club. Any Sam’s Club with a fresh bakery will have a cake catalog with custom options.

Premade cakes are prepared every day. In addition, the Sam’s Club Bakery has many simple designs that you can further customize with your own decorations at home.

For example, you can buy a Sam’s Club birthday cake with colorful balloons on top. Then, you can use your own icing at home to write a message or add other decorations.

Another favorite is the Sam’s Club unicorn cake. This design features a two-tiered cake with a 10” layer and a 5” layer.

The cake is decorated to look like a unicorn, with a horn and ears on top and colorful icing all around.

While the exact design can vary by store, any cake that looks like a unicorn is sure to please the kids at their birthday party!

If you don’t see something you like, talk to a Sam’s Club Bakery employee. They might have other cakes ready that were not yet displayed.

Of course, it may be easier to purchase a custom cake. And with this option, a trained cake decorator will create a beautiful centerpiece for your next celebration.

Sam’s Club custom cakes can be customized to taste and look just the way you want them.

To order a custom cake, you will need to visit the bakery in your local Sam’s Club. Here, you can browse the Sam’s Club cake catalog, which is also available online.

A cake decorator at the bakery can help you narrow down exactly what you want the final product to look like.

At most Sam’s Club locations, you can also place a custom cake order over the phone.

While there is no direct Sam’s Club Bakery phone number, you can call your local store from the number found with the Club Finder, and they will direct you to the bakery department.

You will need to fill out a Sam’s Club cake order form when you place the order in the store.

First, you select the size of your custom cake. Your options include a 10” round, ½ sheet, full sheet, and a combination of a cake and cupcakes.

You can also order a Sam’s Club cookie cake using this order form.

Once you have selected the size, you will need to choose between 3 flavors: white, chocolate, and marble. Note that marble is only available in a ½ or full sheet cake, not a round cake.

If you have cupcakes in your order, there is a separate section for the cupcake flavor with the same options.

Customizing the icing is the next step. Sam’s Club cakes can be made with whipped icing or their version of a buttercream frosting, called But-R-Creme. Both types come in white or chocolate flavors.

Not only can you choose the icing flavor, but you can also select different colors for the icing on other elements of the cake.

For example, if your chosen design has a border and balloons, you can pick different colors for these separate elements.

In addition, the different icing types have other colors available, so there is a large variety for you to find the perfect color.

Next, you can write down any message you want to be written on the cake. Most cake designs have a blank space on top that is perfect for a custom message.

The best messages are short and sweet, with just a few words. Make sure you write your message clearly, so your cake turns out correctly.

The cake order form has the cake design as the last customization step. However, you will likely already know the design you want because it will help guide the other decisions.

You will need to indicate the name of the design on the order form, which is found in the Sam’s Club cake catalog.

Finally, you will need to leave your contact information on the order form for a Sam’s Club Bakery employee to contact you if they have any questions while preparing your order.

You will also need to indicate the date and time to pick up your custom cake order.

Just remember to go to Sam’s Club at least a day or two before you plan to pick up your custom cake order because the bakers need time to bake and decorate your cake.

That being said, a premade cake may be the best option for a last-minute dessert.

Can You Order a Cake From Sam’s Club Online?

You can order a premade cake from Sam’s Club online, but not a custom cake. Cakes ordered online at Sam’s Club can be picked up at many locations or delivered to your house. You must order a cake online at least 24 hours before you plan to pick it up or have it delivered.

To order a cake from Sam’s Club online, you will need to have an online account and a membership with the store.

Depending on how you registered for a membership, you may already have an online account.

Otherwise, link your membership number and information to an online account for easy online ordering.

If you don’t have an account or membership, you can also sign up for a Sam’s Club membership online.

The Sam’s Club membership offers plenty of great benefits, including discounts, same-day delivery, and exclusive fuel prices at Sam’s Club gas stations. The basic membership costs $45 per year.

You could also become a Plus member for $100 per year. This membership gives you more access to rewards, free shipping or pickup, and additional Sam’s Club services like the Pharmacy and Optical departments.

However, you do not need the more expensive Plus membership to order a cake online.

After you have a membership established, you can search for a cake online. The bakery products are found within the Grocery category called “Fresh Food.”

Sam’s Club sells plenty of other fresh baked goods in addition to their cakes, cupcakes, and cookies.

You can use filters on the website to only show items you are interested in. The “Sort by” feature is also helpful if you want to focus on the most highly-rated items or perhaps the cheapest. Take some time to look at all the different options Sam’s Club Bakery offers.

Once you find the perfect cake, you can click “Add to Cart.” However, you may not see this option on some cakes, which means those are meant to be customized only in-store.

Then, you can go to your cart to review your order details and checkout. The checkout process is simple, with easy-to-follow instructions online.

Remember to confirm that the correct receiving method is selected, whether that is Pickup or Delivery.

Does Sam’s Club Make Custom Cakes?

Sam’s Club makes custom cakes for many different occasions. You can customize the cake design and flavor, icing color, and icing flavor. The Sam’s Club cake catalog features all the design options available at your local Sam’s Club Bakery. This catalog even tells you how many people a certain design will feed.

You can only order a custom cake in person at a Sam’s Club. Unfortunately, Sam’s Club does not accept custom cake orders online at this time, though they may become available in the future.

However, you can still view the Sam’s Club cake catalog online.

After browsing the catalog, you should be able to put together your custom cake order.

Your first step should be picking a cake design and big enough size to serve your guests.

Next, the catalog tells you how many people a certain cake will feed. It even tells you the calories per serving.

After picking your design, you’ll need to narrow down flavors and colors. Most Sam’s Club cake designs can be made with white, chocolate, or marble cake.

The cake can be paired with white or chocolate icing. There is also a whipped version of each of these icing flavors.

While many designs have preset color schemes, you can still customize the icing colors on just about any cake.

This is especially fun when you can match a school’s colors for graduation or use the colors of your favorite sports team.

You may run into some trouble if you want chocolate icing in a bright color since the icing is naturally brown. But white icing can be turned into any color of the rainbow.

Many Sam’s Club cake designs let you add a personalized message on top of the cake.

Just like the main decorations, you can choose the color of the icing used to write the message.

Additionally, you can have an edible photo printed on the top of the cake.

Sam’s Club also sells custom “Family Fun Kits” that include a cake or cupcakes along with decorating materials. This customizable kit comes with a ⅛ sheet cake or 15 cupcakes.

What Are Sam’s Club Cake Prices?

Sam’s Club sheet cake prices can range from $14 to $40, depending on how many people you need to serve. With a Sam’s Club membership, you can order various sheet cakes, round cakes, or cupcakes. You can even order a combination of a cake and cupcakes.

The Sam’s Club basic sheet cake designs are highly affordable. You can serve almost 100 people for around $40.

If you choose to customize a cake, your final order total may cost a little more than the basic price; however, this is likely still cheaper than a boutique bakery.

Below is a table depicting estimated prices for Sam’s Club cakes of varying sizes and styles.

Cake SizeNumber of ServingsPrice
1/2 Sheet48$19.98
Full Sheet96$39.98
10” Round14$15.98
2-Tier (10” and 5” Rounds)46$39.98
5” Round with 10 Cupcakes16$13.98
* Sam’s Club Cake Prices May Vary by Location

These prices can vary by location, so it’s best to confirm with a Sam’s Club Bakery employee before finalizing your order.

Does Sam’s Club Make Wedding Cakes?

Sam’s Club makes wedding cakes, though they are not heavily advertised. Nevertheless, Sam’s Club is a great option if you are looking for an affordable wedding cake. Sam’s Club wedding cake designs are simple and elegant, and you can personalize many elements like a regular custom cake order.

If you have a small and intimate wedding, you can order a quarter sheet cake to serve 24 people.

Slightly larger weddings may require a 2- or 3-tier cake, which Sam’s Club can also provide.

You can even order a combination of cake and cupcakes to help you better serve your guests.

A few of the designs in the Sam’s Club online cake catalog match the classic wedding cake look.

“Shimmering Elegance” and “Plaque” are two elegant, simple designs. You can customize these by adding the happy couple’s initials on an edible plaque for the cake.

Does Sam’s Club Bake Their Own Cakes?

Sam’s Club bakes some of their own cakes, including sheet cakes; however, they are only made at Sam’s Club locations with a fresh bakery. The white sheet cake recipe is top-rated, but there are plenty of delicious cakes and other desserts Sam’s Club Bakery makes every day.

You can buy packages of 6 sheet cakes in vanilla, chocolate, or marble flavors. Many caterers like to serve these cakes at their events because they taste great and are easy to decorate.

The Member’s Mark Tres Leches cake is also made fresh in-house. It is soaked in a sweet milk mixture and topped with whipped cream, fruit, and chocolate.

The Member’s Mark Tres Leches cake costs under $20, a great price for a freshly baked cake that serves 14 people.

Conclusion

The Sam’s Club Bakery is a great place to get your next celebratory cake. Customers rave about the delicious desserts made fresh every day, including premade and custom cakes.

If you don’t already have a Sam’s Club membership, sign up for one now so you can get an awesome cake for your next birthday party!

If you’re interested in finding out more tips about shopping at Sam’s Club, check out the related articles below.

Related Articles:

Sam’s Club Membership: Everything You Need to Know

Member’s Mark: Deconstructing Sam’s Club Store Brand

Sam’s Club Delivery: How to Order and Get Membership Perks on Instacart

Sam’s Club Pickup: How It Works and Tips to Get Started

Does Sam’s Club Take EBT? (Yes, but Not Online)

Was this article helpful?

Last Updated: March 18, 2022

About the Author

Alex Burgess is a registered dietitian and content creator with over two years of experience. She loves sharing nutrition information and has a passion for studying gut health.

During her free time, she enjoys hiking with friends, cooking a new recipe for her family, or watching her dog frolic at the dog park.

Recent Articles