Select Page

The Best Things to Order From Steak ‘n Shake

Founded in 1934 in Normal, Illinois, Steak ‘n Shake is famous for its burgers and milkshakes with a group of loyal fans who swear by their menu items.

Steak ‘n Shake burgers are made from never-frozen, freshly grilled steaks that are slightly crispy on the edges but juicy and flavorful throughout.

Their milkshakes are made fresh from vanilla ice cream with a variety of flavors to satisfy any palate.

In addition to burgers and milkshakes, the Steak ‘n Shake menu includes delicious hot dogs and sandwiches under one roof.

In this article, we’ve rounded up the 19 best Steak ‘n Shake menu items ranked from great to must-tries!

19. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Milkshake

If you are looking for something to satisfy your sweet tooth, look no further than Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup milkshake.

You can’t go wrong when you throw peanut butter and chocolate together in one scrumptious shake.

Crushed pieces of Reese’s chocolate cups are included in this creamy concoction, along with vanilla ice cream and chocolate sauce, adding texture and an extra shot of sweetness.

The salt-and-sweet combo makes it a perfect treat for any peanut butter lover.

Nutritional Information:

760 calories, 16g protein, 123g carbohydrates, 26g fat

18. Grilled Cheese

Steak ‘n Shake’s Grilled Cheese is made with two slices of Texas toast that have been buttered and grilled until golden brown and crispy.

Between these two slices of golden toast lies two slices of American cheese melted to the right consistency.

The American cheese in this sandwich is made with real milk for a creamy, melty texture.

This classic combination of buttery toast and melted cheese is perfect for those days when you need something comforting.

It is also a great choice for any picky kids in the family.

Nutritional Information:

650 calories, 25g protein, 41g carbohydrates, 41g fat

17. Oreo Cookies n’ Cream Milkshake

If you’re a fan of McDonald’s Oreo McFlurry, you’ll love the Oreo Cookies n’ Cream milkshake.

This shake is made with real ice cream and topped with fluffy whipped cream plus heaps of crushed Oreos for an extra crunchy chocolate experience.

You get to enjoy the creaminess from the ice cream and then the crunchiness from all those cookie bits.

It’s like eating an ice cream sandwich without worrying about your fingers getting sticky afterward.

Nutritional Information:

730 calories, 15g protein, 121g carbohydrates, 23g fat

16. Oreo Mint Cookie Milkshake

Get ready to tantalize your taste buds with an even more tasty Oreo Cookies n’ Cream milkshake!

The cool minty syrup will please your palate, and the crushed Oreo cookie pieces add more flavor and a crunchy texture.

Plus, velvety smooth ice cream gives you an extra heavenly touch on each sip.

I can’t tell you how much I love this milkshake!

Nutritional Information:

730 calories, 15g protein, 118g carbohydrates, 23g fat

15. Frisco Melt

Let’s start with the foundation: two juicy all-beef patties are grilled to perfection and placed on a bed of melted Swiss and American cheese.

But instead of the usual bun, the Frisco Melt is served on two slices of Texas Toast for an extra crunchy texture.

The patties are made with 100% beef that’s ground fresh daily, while the special sauce used on this burger is a closely guarded secret.

Whether you eat it plain, slip some onion rings, or dip it in chili, the Frisco Melt is a must-try on the Steak ‘n Shake menu.

Nutritional Information:

960 calories, 34g protein, 51g carbohydrates, 66g fat

14. Steak Frank

A quality hot dog is so hard to come by these days.

Some of the sausages are filled with pink slime or other mysterious ingredients.

But the hot dog used in the Steak Frank is made of fresh beef steak and blended spices for flavor.

It is cooked just right and served on a warm bun slathered with mustard, ketchup, and an optional helping of chopped onions.

It’s the perfect snack when you want something simple yet satisfying.

When you add a cheesy chili to the mix, it becomes an even bigger flavor bomb.

This might be the ticket if you have a picky kid to feed.

Nutritional Information:

390 calories, 13g protein, 32g carbohydrates, 23g fat

13. Double Steakburger Double Cheese

If you’re looking for an unparalleled dining experience, the Double Steakburger Double Cheese will not disappoint.

This burger combines two 4-ounce steak patties, two slices of American cheese, caramelized onions, pickles, ketchup, and mustard, all piled onto a lightly toasted bun.

Every bite creates a flavor explosion that will satisfy any steak or cheese enthusiast.

The creaminess of the American cheese makes each bite delectable while lending an extra layer of depth.

The sweetness from the pickles creates a perfect contrast to ketchup and mustard, plus adds extra texture to every mouthful.

Nutritional Information:

530 calories, 28g protein, 33g carbohydrates, 33g fat

12. Cotton Candy Milkshake

Bring out the child in you with the Cotton Candy milkshake!

This delightful shake is made with creamy vanilla ice cream, blue cotton candy syrup, and a topping of fluffy whipped cream.

It has all the flavors in a cup.

As someone who adores cotton candy, this shake has pleasantly surprised me.

Nutritional Information:

620 calories, 15g protein, 96g carbohydrates, 21g fat

11. Western BBQ ‘n Bacon Steakburger

When it comes to burgers, the BBQ sauce can make or break your experience.

Steak ‘n Shake understands that and has crafted the Western BBQ ‘n Bacon Steakburger with a sweet, smokey barbeque sauce that takes this burger up a notch.

Two steak patties, cheese, bacon strips, and fried onions, all topped off with their house-made BBQ sauce, will leave you wondering why you have not tried it sooner.

The combination of savory and sweet makes for a flavor that will tantalize your taste buds.

Nutritional Information:

790 calories, 35g protein, 54g carbohydrates, 43g fat

10. Birthday Cake Milkshake

The scent of the birthday cake in this shake will bring back all your wonderful memories!

Made with vanilla ice cream, yellow birthday cake, and rainbow sprinkles, the Birthday Cake milkshake will make any day feel like a celebration.

And kids can get extra excited about the cheerful colors from all those little sprinkles!

Nutritional Information:

840 calories, 16g protein, 135g carbohydrates, 27g fat

9. Bacon ‘n Cheese Double Steakburger

The Bacon’ n Cheese Double Steakburger includes two beef patties stacked with American cheese, crunchy bacon strips, tomatoes, lettuce, and onion slices, all between Steak ‘n Shake’s signature buns.

This burger is perfect for those looking to savor their love for beef and bacon in one meal.

Bite into the juicy, smokey charbroiled patties with a hint of saltiness from crunchy bacon pieces and creamy cheese for an unforgettable flavor experience.

Layers of fresh tomatoes, lettuce, onion slices, pickles, and sauces provide delightful sweetness and crispness to every bite.

This hearty steakburger creates a taste sensation that will tantalize any carnivore’s palate.

Nutritional Information:

600 calories, 31g protein, 29g carbohydrates, 38g fat

8. M&M’s Milkshake

There’s always something to the delightful crunch and creamy chocolate center of M&Ms.

When you combine vanilla ice cream and chunks of delicious M&M’s and top it off with whipped cream for an extra indulgent finish, this milkshake becomes the perfect way to get your fix for chocolatey goodness.

The M&M’s milkshake goes so well with a grilled cheese sandwich and some fries.

Nutritional Information:

790 calories, 16g protein, 129g carbohydrates, 25g fat

7. Butter Double Steakburger

The combination of brioche bun and Steak ‘n Shake’s beef patty is a match made in heaven, and the Butter Double Steakburger is no exception.

This burger includes two beef patties between a buttery brioche bun loaded with lettuce, tomato, pickles, and onions.

It’s then topped with a creamy garlic mayo sauce that combines the perfect blend of salty goodness and sweetness.

The soft, buttery brioche bun melts in your mouth, and the flavor of the patties explodes with every bite.

Nutritional Information:

870 calories, 28g protein, 34g carbohydrates, 65g fat

6. Chili 5-Way

The Chili 5-Way is a classic Steak ‘n Shake menu item that has been around since the 1950s.

It combines spaghetti noodles with chili, onions, beans, and shredded cheese.

The beef chili is made with ground steak, tomato sauce, onion powder, garlic powder, black pepper, cumin powder, and other spices.

The spaghetti noodles are cooked al dente before being mixed with the chili.

There’s something about the combination of spicy chili with springy pasta and gooey cheese that works so well together.

The spiciness of the chili will give you a nice tingly aftertaste but not enough to make you sweat.

If you find the combo of spaghetti and chili a little strange, you can just get the chili by itself.

Nutritional Information:

1160 calories, 59g protein, 103g carbohydrates, 57g fat

5. Kit-Kat Milkshake

As an avid fan of the chocolate bar, I was excited to try Steak ‘n Shake’s rendition of the Kit-Kat milkshake.

The delightful blend of crunchy wafer cookie pieces and chocolate syrup creates a heavenly flavor experience.

The whipped cream and the cherry on top make it even sweeter.

Nutritional Information:

710 calories, 16g protein, 114g carbohydrates, 22g fat

4. Butterfinger Milkshake

Butterfinger stands apart from other candies thanks to its remarkable combination of peanuts, chocolate, and those flaky hard caramel layers.

Steak ‘n Shake’s Butterfinger milkshake is the ideal embodiment of this unique flavor – salty and sweet in perfect harmony.

It includes a creamy vanilla ice cream base, where hints of melted caramel pieces are intertwined with the smoothness of whipped cream and topped off with chocolate sauce.

Nutritional Information:

760 calories, 16g protein, 126g carbohydrates, 23g fat

3. Triple Steakburger (3x Cheese)

If you are looking for something like In ‘n Out’s beast burger, this is it.

The Triple Steakburger (3x Cheese) has three beef patties stacked in toasted buns and topped with three slices of American cheese, pickles, ketchup, mustard, and onion.

The juicy steaks and melted cheese create a unique flavor profile that will have you hooked after the first bite.

The savory beef, sweet pickles, tangy ketchup, and mustard are a match made in heaven.

Nutritional Information:

840 calories, 42g protein, 32g carbohydrates, 52g fat

2. Nutella Milkshake

Indulging in Nutella straight from the jar has always been my guilty pleasure, but the Nutella milkshake takes it to a new level.

Imagine creamy vanilla ice cream blended with decadent hazelnut and chocolate flavors, making each sip of this shake special.

With its velvety texture and intense taste, this milkshake is at the top of my list when I visit Steak ‘n Shake.

Nutritional Information:

820 calories, 18g protein, 109g carbohydrates, 37g fat

1. Garlic Double Steakburger

Steak ‘n Shake’s buttery garlic brioche bread is nothing short of heavenly!

When combined with two juicy beef patties and American cheese, it becomes a burger that will have most burger enthusiasts sing their praises.

The Garlic Double Steakburger also boasts lettuce, tomatoes, and mayonnaise to add texture and flavor, making this the best burger on the Steak ‘n Shake menu.

Nutritional Information:

730 calories, 28g protein, 33g carbohydrates, 50g fat


Steak ‘n Shake offers a wide variety of menu items, including milkshakes, burgers, hot dogs, and sandwiches under one roof.

All menu items are made with fresh ingredients and a dash of creativity, making them stand out as a fast-food chain.

Next time you want to brighten your day, try some of the Steak ‘n Shake menu items on this list and savor your wonderful memories!

For more information about Steak ‘n Shake, check out the articles below.

About the Author

Lianne Fachetti is a content writer who adores food from all cultures. When she’s not working, she’s busy creating new recipes, trying out new restaurants, playing with her German Shepherd Max, and tending to her vegetable garden.


September 2, 2023