Select Page

The Most Popular Flavors at Cold Stone

Cold Stone is known for having unique, flavorful ice cream mixtures and offers plenty of flavors to choose from. Not only does Cold Stone have a wide selection of ice cream flavors, but it also has mix-ins, or toppings, that you can add.

The toppings at Cold Stone include classics like fudge, bananas, sprinkles, and chocolate chips, as well as more unique toppings, like apple pie filling and chocolate shavings.

You can get large quantities of Cold Stone ice cream by going to your local store and ordering a Mix & Go container. Cold Stone will fill it with your favorite flavor of ice cream and add any toppings you wish.

Cold Stone ice cream is available in three sizes: Like It (5 oz), Love It (8 oz), and Gotta Have It (12 oz).

Note that most Cold Stone ice cream flavors have lactose, but all their sorbet flavors are lactose-free.

In addition, Cold Stone offers light and low-fat ice cream; however, they do not have sugar-free ice cream.

If you are craving ice cream at Cold Stone but aren’t sure what to order, don’t worry; we have you covered!

In this article, we’ve compiled a list of the best Cold Stone ice cream flavors based on their taste, texture, and overall experience.

Read on to learn about our top picks and see how your favorites stack up!

15. Mint

First on our list, we have Cold Stone’s mint-flavored ice cream. This ice cream tastes refreshing, and it is incredibly creamy.

To take Cold Stone’s Mint ice cream to the next level, customize it with chocolate chips, fudge, or cookie crumbles. Mint and chocolate is a classic combination, so you can’t really go wrong.

If you aren’t sure how to customize it, some Cold Stone locations have signature creations using their mint ice cream, like the Cookie Mintster and the Mint Mint Chocolate Chocolate Chip.

The Mint ice cream isn’t lactose-free, but it doesn’t contain ingredients with eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, soy, and wheat gluten.

A Love It size Mint ice cream with no toppings has 550 calories, 60 grams of carbs, and 53 grams of sugar.

14. Vanilla Lite

For those looking for a light option, Cold Stone has you covered with their Vanilla Lite ice cream.

Though it’s labeled light, it still has the classic taste of vanilla ice cream that we all know and love. The only difference is that there is no added sugar.

The Vanilla Lite ice cream goes with any of Cold Stone’s toppings.

However, if you want to keep it light and fresh, we recommend adding various fruits—like blueberries, strawberries, bananas, etc.

There isn’t a signature creation that features their Vanilla Lite ice cream; however, you can swap any creation made with Cold Stone’s sweet cream with the Vanilla Lite.

With no toppings, the Love It size has 330 calories, 63 grams of carbs, and 15 grams of sugar.

This ice cream contains ingredients that have dairy.

13. Strawberry

Cold Stone’s Strawberry ice cream is sweet, creamy, and quite delicious. It is part of the ice cream trifecta with chocolate and vanilla, but it also stands well on its own.

We’ll admit the sweetness gets a little too much with each bite, but you can add any topping you’d like to add some texture and balance the sweetness.

Cold Stone highlights their Strawberry flavor in a couple of signature creations, like the Our Strawberry Blonde and Surrender to Strawberry.

Just because it’s named after a fruit doesn’t mean it’s healthy.

The Love It size of the Strawberry ice cream, with no toppings, has 520 calories, 59 grams of carbs, and 54 grams of sugar.

The Strawberry ice cream has ingredients that contain dairy.

12. Dark Chocolate Peppermint

Cold Stone’s Dark Chocolate Peppermint is a seasonal flavor typically available after Thanksgiving.

Both flavors of chocolate and peppermint can be tasted throughout, and this combination might be just what you need to bring you the holiday spirit.

The Dark Chocolate Peppermint is rich and creamy. We recommend customizing it with cookie crumbles, sprinkles, or sugar crystals to add more texture.

Cold Stone features Dark Chocolate Peppermint ice cream in their seasonal signature creation, the Chocolate Peppermint Perfection.

This ice cream has ingredients that contain dairy and soy.

The Love It size with no toppings has 510 calories, 57 grams of carbs, and 49 grams of sugar.

11. Coffee

Our next flavor is for coffee lovers only! Cold Stone’s Coffee ice cream is rich, creamy, and even has a touch of caffeine.

You can customize this ice cream with whatever you want—but we love adding caramel and Heath bar crumbles to turn the ice cream up a notch.

Cold Stone has some signature creations made with Coffee ice cream, like the Coffee Lovers Only and the Mud Pie Mojo.

The Coffee ice cream without any toppings has ingredients that contain dairy.

If you get it in the Love It size, it has 540 calories, 58 grams of carbs, and 52 grams of sugar.

10. Classic Cookie Dough

Cookie dough may not be for everyone, but we can’t express enough how delicious Cold Stone’s Classic Cookie Dough ice cream really is!

There aren’t bits of cookie dough in the ice cream itself, which makes the texture of this ice cream quite smooth.

Feel free to customize the Cookie Dough ice cream and make it your own!

You can add bites of cookie dough and chocolate chips or even brownie bites if you want some fudgy texture.

Cold Stone features their Classic Cookie Dough ice cream in numerous signature creations.

You can find it in the One Smart Brookie, Way the Cookie Crumbles, Somewhere Over the Rain-Dough, Dough-lightful Peanut Butter, and Dough for It.

The Classic Cookie Dough ice cream mixture contains dairy and gluten.

With Love It size, this ice cream has 590 calories, 79 grams of carbs, and 60 grams of sugar.

9. Sweet Cream

Cold Stone’s Sweet Cream ice cream is a classic among Cold Stone regulars. Not only are half of their cakes made up of it, but Cold Stone also released a coffee creamer with this flavor.

The Sweet Cream is like vanilla ice cream, with a creamy consistency and a little sweeter flavor profile.

All of Cold Stone’s toppings go well with this one, so you can let your imagination run wild!

Many of their signature creations have Sweet Cream ice cream, including the Berry Berry Berry Good, Founder’s Favorite, Oreo Overload, and Reese’s Peanut Butter Awesome Sauce.

The Sweet Cream ice cream contains ingredients that have dairy.

Without any toppings, the Love It size has 540 calories, 58 grams of carbs, and 52 grams of sugar.

8. Pumpkin

When the leaves begin to change, almost every chain restaurant comes out with a seasonal pumpkin-flavored menu item. So, it isn’t a surprise that Cold Stone has pumpkin-flavored ice cream when fall hits.

The Pumpkin ice cream is silky and sweet, and you can add any of their mix-ins you’d like.

However, this flavor goes particularly well with apples, graham cracker pie crust, and cinnamon.

Cold Stone has signature creations featuring Pumpkin ice cream, like their Pumpkin in the Sky. It can also be found in their seasonal pumpkin pie.

Cold Stone’s Pumpkin ice cream has ingredients that contain dairy.

Without any toppings, the Love It size has 460 calories, 56 grams of carbs, and 51 grams of sugar.

7. French Vanilla

Who knew that French vanilla could be used for something other than coffee? Cold Stone’s French Vanilla ice cream is creamy and milk, with a bold amount of sweetness.

French vanilla is another popular ice cream flavor among Cold Stone goers.

It goes well with all of Cold Stone’s toppings, but it is especially good with berries and candy.

Signature creations with the French Vanilla ice cream include the Apple Pie a la Cold Stone, Banana Caramel Crunch, and Cookie Doughn’t You Want Some.

Cold Stone’s French Vanilla ice cream has ingredients that contain eggs and dairy.

Without any toppings, the Love It size has 550 calories, 60 grams of carbs, and 55 grams of sugar.

6. Peanut Butter Cookie Dough

Cold Stone’s Peanut Butter Cookie Dough takes the classic cookie dough flavor to another level.

Any peanut butter lover can enjoy this flavor of ice cream to its fullest. It’s both smooth and rich and tastes like a peanut butter cookie.

If you want to go extreme and pack as much peanut butter flavor as possible, you can go all out and add all their peanut butter toppings.

Chocolate and peanut butter also go well together—so feel free to add fudge or chocolate chips to this one.

The Peanut Butter Cookie Dough isn’t in as many signature creations as Cold Stone’s other flavors, but you can find it in the PB Dough Delight and the Peanut Butter Pretzel Time.

Peanut butter naturally has a lot of fat, so unsurprisingly, the calories and carbs are high in this ice cream.

The Love It size has 610 calories, 73 grams of carbs, and 57 grams of sugar.

This ice cream flavor also has ingredients that contain dairy, peanuts, and gluten.

5. Chocolate

Chocolate is almost everyone’s favorite ice cream, and it’s one of the most popular flavors at Cold Stone. Their Chocolate ice cream is rich and decadent, and it’s hard to put it down!

Chocolate ice cream goes well with a variety of toppings, but we specifically like adding some bursts of color—like sprinkles, gummy bears, or M&Ms.

Cold Stone features its Chocolate ice cream in a couple of signature creations and its ice cream cakes.

If you want to try one of their inspired sundaes, you can get the Chocolate Devotion, Germanchökolätekäke, or Peanut Butter Cup Perfection.

Cold Stone’s Chocolate ice cream contains ingredients that have dairy.

Without toppings, the Love It size has 520 calories, 54 grams of carbs, and 51 grams of sugar.

4. Cheesecake

Cheesecake might be one of America’s favorite cakes—well, it’s also one of our favorite Cold Stone ice cream flavors!

Cold Stone’s Cheesecake ice cream tastes just like the cheesecake you’d get from the bakery down the road. It’s sweet, thick, and creamy.

The Cheesecake flavor goes well with any of Cold Stone’s toppings, but we recommend throwing in a variety of berries to add some freshness.

Cold Stone’s signature creation on deck with this ice cream flavor is Cheesecake Fantasy—a cheesecake lover’s dream!

The Cheesecake ice cream flavor is also the main ingredient in Cold Stone’s ice cream cake called A Cheesecake Named Desire.

Cold Stone’s Cheesecake ice cream mixture has ingredients that contain dairy.

With no toppings, the Love It size has 540 calories, 63 grams of carbs, and 53 grams of sugar.

3. Eggnog

Cold eggnog is the best drink to sip on by the winter fireside, and Cold Stone created an ice cream flavor that tastes just like it.

Cold Stone’s Eggnog ice cream is smooth, creamy, and rich. It practically mirrors the classic Christmas drink, but we’ll admit it’s a little lighter than the actual one.

Just like any of their other flavors, you can customize it with any toppings you wish.

However, we recommend adding cinnamon and the graham cracker pie crust to give it some extra flavor.

The Eggnog ice cream mixture has ingredients that contain eggs, dairy, soy, and gluten.

If you get this ice cream in the Love It size, it has 430 calories, 45 grams of carbs, and 41 grams of sugar.

2. Pumpkin Cheesecake

In the fall season, we all crave anything that tastes pumpkin, and Cold Stone has two seasonal pumpkin ice cream flavors. The Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream is our favorite of the two!

Cold Stone’s Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream is creamy and rich, just like their cheesecake.

Though pumpkin and cheesecake are strong flavors, they are well-balanced in the mixture.

You can add any toppings you like to the ice cream—but the cinnamon, graham cracker pie crust, and caramel go very well with it.

There aren’t any signature creations with this ice cream flavor; however, you can get it in their pumpkin cheesecake ice cream pie.

Cold Stone’s Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream is typically available after November.

It contains ingredients that have dairy, and the Love It size has 510 calories, 60 grams of carbs, and 52 grams of sugar.

1. Cake Batter

And finally, the most popular ice cream flavor at Cold Stone, and our personal favorite, is the Cake Batter!

This sweet ice cream is consistent with the texture of the actual cake batter—thick and creamy.

If you love cake just as much as we do, Cold Stone’s Cake Batter ice cream mixture was made for you.

In addition, any of Cold Stone’s toppings go well with it—so you can easily make it your own.

Because Cake Batter is Cold Stone’s most popular ice cream flavor, there are plenty of signature creations available, including the seasonal Trick or Treat, Birthday Cake Remix, Cake Batter Batter Batter, and Cookies Make Everything Batter.

The Cake Batter ice cream has ingredients that contain dairy and gluten.

Without any toppings, the Love It size has 580 calories, 71 grams of carbs, and 58 grams of sugar.

Local Flavors at Cold Stone

In addition to the signature ice cream flavors available at Cold Stone seasonally or throughout the year, local Cold Stone stores also have other flavors you can choose from.

Depending on your location, the local ice cream flavors at Cold Stone include:

  • Butter Pecan
  • Amaretto
  • Lemon Sorbet
  • Caramel Latte
  • Banana
  • Chocolate Cake Batter
  • Black Cherry
  • Orange Dreamsickle
  • Coconut
  • Cinnamon Bun Batter
  • Golden Oreo Cookie
  • Mango
  • Oatmeal Cookie Batter
  • Vanilla Bean
  • Dark Chocolate
  • Fudge Brownie Batter
  • Mocha
  • Peach
  • Pistachio
  • Raspberry Sorbet
  • Watermelon Sorbet
  • Peanut Butter
  • Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
  • Marshmallow
  • Reese’s Chocolate Peanut Butter
  • Oreo Crème
  • Cotton Candy
  • Raspberry
  • Cinnamon

All these flavors are as delicious as their signature flavors, so check your local Cold Stone to see which flavors are available in your area.


If you are craving a sweet treat, Cold Stone has a wide selection of ice cream flavors that can satisfy any taste bud.

Not only can you customize Cold Stone’s ice cream flavors with their mix-ins, but you can also try any of their signature creations.

Cold Stone often comes up with new flavors, and some are spins on their classic, popular flavors, like the Cake Batter and Cookie Dough. So make sure to check what your local Cold Stone carries.

For more information about Cold Stone, check out the articles below.

About the Author

Tiana Guzman is a content writer and an avid foodie who likes to try new restaurants and cuisines while uncovering new recipes to cook at home.

In her free time, she enjoys taking hikes, playing with her dogs, and having a movie and game night with friends and family.

October 24, 2023